Comics, book, and DVD reviews (and occasional eruptions of other kinds)
Wednesday, September 25, 2013
The GUIDE Makes Me Perplexed
Five cogent comments on TV GUIDE's recently published list of "the 60 greatest cartoons of all time":
(1) What, precisely, qualifies as a "TV cartoon"? TVG doesn't seem to know. Putting rebroadcasts of classic theatrical cartoons on the same "level" as made-for-TV series makes no sense, unless you're talking about things like the early-60s Popeye cartoons or The Bugs Bunny Show.
(2) NO Disney Afternoon series??? Well, Disney has no one to blame but itself for that sad fact, given how little respect its video and PR divisions have shown for the marvelous products of the "WDTVA Golden Age." I'm not going to grouse about the presence of Kim Possible on the list, but it's hard to countenance Phineas and Ferb making the cut but such series as DuckTales, TaleSpin, Darkwing Duck, and Gargoyles being left out.
(3) There isn't quite as much "presentism" apparent in this list as I'd originally feared. Sure, there's a clear overrepresentation of 21st-century series, but the inclusion of Huckleberry Hound, Yogi Bear, The Flintstones, and several other "old-screen" Hanna-Barbera favorites -- not to mention the evergreen Rocky and Bullwinkle -- should be at least somewhat gratifying to those of us of a certain age (including those who, like me, watched these shows in syndication). Listing Scooby-Doo at #5 may be pushing things, however.
(4) I'm a bit surprised at the lack of anime series on the list. Not that I was seriously expecting Astro Boy or Kimba the White Lion to make the cut, but no Speed Racer? No Pokemon? No Sailor Moon? The latter two omissions are particularly noteworthy -- and chilling. I have in my mind's eye visions of San Diego Cons of 15 to 20 years ago, at which Poke-players and cosplaying "Moonies" were such a massive presence. (Then again, people selling and collecting Pogs were also easily found at that time.) Bronies are currently all kinds of excited over My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic's appearance on the list. Let us hope that history does not repeat itself.
(5) Jem and the Holograms... Thundercats... He-Man. The rest is silence.
Tuesday, September 24, 2013
Comics Review: MY LITTLE PONY MICRO-SERIES #8: CELESTIA (IDW Publishing, September 2013)
After feeling their way through the issues devoted to the "Mane 6," the merry minions responsible for the MICRO-SERIES title really seem to have hit their stride. First came a Cutie Mark Crusaders issue of surprisingly high quality; now we are gifted with something even more remarkable, a first-rate story featuring Princess Celestia. In order to get the job done, writer Georgia Ball and artist Amy Mebberson had to swim upstream while battling a whole host of "neigh-sayers" in the MLP fan base who've long dismissed Celestia as a manipulative, personality-challenged, "too-perfect-to-be-true" god-ruler. By keeping the central story simple and humble AND permitting the ruler of Equestria to display her tougher, more physical side in a flashback battle scene, Ball and Mebberson cover all the necessary bases: they show a ruler who can get her hooves dirty when necessary and also display fierce loyalty to a beloved subject, even in the face of some social disapproval.
** SPOILERS **
Celestia defending an elderly, paranoid, increasingly-out-of-touch teacher who's become the laughingstock of "Celestia's School for Gifted Unicorns"? What's the pony equivalent of, "You had me at hello"? Once again, Canterlot society is shown to be a rather hard-edged place, as the aging Inkwell, who once helped Celestia fight off an invasion of... um, somethings, is now being routinely mocked by parents and students alike (including, sorry to say, a trio of red, blue, and green-hatted little ponies who are obviously meant to evoke the "color-coded" Nephews of DuckTales -- or at least a somewhat-ruder-than-normal version of same). At the hearing which will decide Inkwell's fate, Celestia reminds those in attendance of how the old teacher helped them in the past and more or less manipulates them into allowing Inkwell to retire on her own terms. Yes, I said "manipulates" -- only here, the reader is not likely to react in the same manner that a lot of Bronies did when Celestia proclaimed that Twilight Sparkle was "ready to fulfill her destiny" (and transform into an Alicorn Princess) in the TV episode "Magical Mystery Cure." This is a broader version of Celestia's famously solicitous treatment of her prize pupil Twilight; it illustrates the princess' great concern for all of her subjects, even ones who have long since given their best to Equestria.
Sabrina Alberghetti's fine cover is a little "dated" in that it displays the "three princesses of Equestria" -- Celestia, Princess Luna, and Princess Cadance -- while leaving Princess Twilight Sparkle out. Well, I think that that little omission will be well and truly corrected once season four begins. I do, however, have to ask: Why is Princess Celestia not Queen Celestia? Once Luna went over to the "dark side" and became Nightmare Moon, leaving Celestia with the responsibility of raising both the Sun and the Moon, wouldn't Celestia have become Queen by default? Oh, I know the answer: Princesses are "cute," "cool," and eminently marketable, while Queens are not. It still seems to me as if Celestia has reason to complain.
** SPOILERS **
Celestia defending an elderly, paranoid, increasingly-out-of-touch teacher who's become the laughingstock of "Celestia's School for Gifted Unicorns"? What's the pony equivalent of, "You had me at hello"? Once again, Canterlot society is shown to be a rather hard-edged place, as the aging Inkwell, who once helped Celestia fight off an invasion of... um, somethings, is now being routinely mocked by parents and students alike (including, sorry to say, a trio of red, blue, and green-hatted little ponies who are obviously meant to evoke the "color-coded" Nephews of DuckTales -- or at least a somewhat-ruder-than-normal version of same). At the hearing which will decide Inkwell's fate, Celestia reminds those in attendance of how the old teacher helped them in the past and more or less manipulates them into allowing Inkwell to retire on her own terms. Yes, I said "manipulates" -- only here, the reader is not likely to react in the same manner that a lot of Bronies did when Celestia proclaimed that Twilight Sparkle was "ready to fulfill her destiny" (and transform into an Alicorn Princess) in the TV episode "Magical Mystery Cure." This is a broader version of Celestia's famously solicitous treatment of her prize pupil Twilight; it illustrates the princess' great concern for all of her subjects, even ones who have long since given their best to Equestria.
Sabrina Alberghetti's fine cover is a little "dated" in that it displays the "three princesses of Equestria" -- Celestia, Princess Luna, and Princess Cadance -- while leaving Princess Twilight Sparkle out. Well, I think that that little omission will be well and truly corrected once season four begins. I do, however, have to ask: Why is Princess Celestia not Queen Celestia? Once Luna went over to the "dark side" and became Nightmare Moon, leaving Celestia with the responsibility of raising both the Sun and the Moon, wouldn't Celestia have become Queen by default? Oh, I know the answer: Princesses are "cute," "cool," and eminently marketable, while Queens are not. It still seems to me as if Celestia has reason to complain.
Labels:
Animation,
Disney Afternoon,
DuckTales,
General Comics,
MLP:FIM,
Movies
Book Review: THE MAN WHO SAVED THE UNION: ULYSSES GRANT IN WAR AND PEACE by H.W. Brands (Anchor, 2013)
The latest installment in Brands' "American Series" (my designation, not his or his publishers') of biographies of important figures in U.S. history takes on Ulysses S. Grant, whose status as one of America's leading military figures has long since been assured, but whose two-term Presidency (1869-1877) has generally been denigrated as a cesspool of incompetence and corruption. Brands' book is virtually "all torso," concentrating on Grant's military exploits in the Mexican and Civil Wars and his eight years as President while paying relatively little attention to his boyhood, family life, and home life. Just about the only "extraneous" part of the biography that rouses any real interest from the reader is the story of the cancer-stricken, dying Grant's struggle to finish his memoirs (and, by so doing, to make up for bad investments that had left him virtually penniless and thereby provide for his family after his death).
Brands doesn't gloss over Grant's mistakes as a military commander but makes it clear why he was such an effective leader of men. Grant was the type of leader who picked intensely loyal subordinates (William T. Sherman being only the most famous) and relied upon them to do their jobs with minimal interference. Alas, the good judgment that had served him so well during the war let him down at crucial times when it came time to pick associates and choose policies in his Presidential administration. Brands argues that Grant deserves more respect as a far-sighted leader in the area of civil rights, supporting civil rights bills, using the military to protect the right of Southern blacks and Southern Republicans to vote, and crushing the first iteration of the Ku Klux Klan. Grant also tried to do right by Native Americans in various ways during his two terms. The problem was that he was unable to convince a sufficient number of followers that his more progressive approach to the problems of Reconstruction and Indian relations was the best way to proceed. Famously reticent as a speaker, Grant lacked the ability or the willingness to use the "bully pulpit" to its fullest, which, given his heroic stature as the general who saved the Union, seems a great shame. On the economic front, Grant's hard-money response to the Panic of 1873, while understandable in light of the strong desire to get back to "sound money" following the use of paper currency during the war, may have prolonged the hard times. The scandals that all but ruined Grant's second term (none of which were directly Grant's fault, except insofar as he trusted some individuals who turned out to be untrustworthy) only added to the popular image of Grant as a financial ignoramus. Even with all of the troubles, Grant ended his second term as a popular icon and was widely credited with helping to heal at least some of the wounds from the civil conflict by his sheer gravitas.
Brands' semi-revisionist work won't necessarily convince you that Grant deserves to be ranked among the greatest Presidents, but the author's more nuanced portrait of the soldier and the statesman may increase your respect for Grant as a humble man of integrity who too often poured his faith in fellow men into flawed vessels.
Brands doesn't gloss over Grant's mistakes as a military commander but makes it clear why he was such an effective leader of men. Grant was the type of leader who picked intensely loyal subordinates (William T. Sherman being only the most famous) and relied upon them to do their jobs with minimal interference. Alas, the good judgment that had served him so well during the war let him down at crucial times when it came time to pick associates and choose policies in his Presidential administration. Brands argues that Grant deserves more respect as a far-sighted leader in the area of civil rights, supporting civil rights bills, using the military to protect the right of Southern blacks and Southern Republicans to vote, and crushing the first iteration of the Ku Klux Klan. Grant also tried to do right by Native Americans in various ways during his two terms. The problem was that he was unable to convince a sufficient number of followers that his more progressive approach to the problems of Reconstruction and Indian relations was the best way to proceed. Famously reticent as a speaker, Grant lacked the ability or the willingness to use the "bully pulpit" to its fullest, which, given his heroic stature as the general who saved the Union, seems a great shame. On the economic front, Grant's hard-money response to the Panic of 1873, while understandable in light of the strong desire to get back to "sound money" following the use of paper currency during the war, may have prolonged the hard times. The scandals that all but ruined Grant's second term (none of which were directly Grant's fault, except insofar as he trusted some individuals who turned out to be untrustworthy) only added to the popular image of Grant as a financial ignoramus. Even with all of the troubles, Grant ended his second term as a popular icon and was widely credited with helping to heal at least some of the wounds from the civil conflict by his sheer gravitas.
Brands' semi-revisionist work won't necessarily convince you that Grant deserves to be ranked among the greatest Presidents, but the author's more nuanced portrait of the soldier and the statesman may increase your respect for Grant as a humble man of integrity who too often poured his faith in fellow men into flawed vessels.
Monday, September 23, 2013
DUCKTALES RETROSPECTIVE: Episode 54, "Spies in Their Eyes"
Merry Christmas! Well, 1987-style, anyway. You know that we're getting close to the end of season one when we see the first of the "clutch" of episodes that aired in late December 1987 and January 1988 following the series' initial few reruns. GeoX found it strange that "Spies in Their Eyes," with its Donald/Navy theme, was immediately followed by another such episode (namely, "All Ducks on Deck"), but there actually was a five-day gap between the original broadcasts, so the "repetition issue" didn't seem like such a much at the time.
"Spies" is a fairly solid effort with a couple of strong one-shot (at least in animated form) guest villains livening things up considerably, but I can't rate it with the series' four-star eps for a couple of key reasons. The theme of Donald being falsely accused of "espionage and high treason" could have made for a really thrilling denouement, with Scrooge, HD&L, and their temporary ally Cinnamon Teal hustling to stop superspy Victor Luzer's theft of the "attack sub experimental" and prove Donald's innocence before Donald is subjected to a court-martial. Since the real penalty that would have been facing Seaman Duck for such crimes would have been death or, at the very least, lengthy imprisonment at hard labor, the others' goal would have been to preempt the legal proceedings themselves. Here, however, writers Sharman DiVono and Bruce Reid Schaefer seem to get their legal wires crossed and conflate the "court martial" with Donald being "drummed out of the Navy." In other words, Donald has every right to whine in the scene below, because he's the victim in what amounts to a show trial. "Sentence first, verdict afterwards!" The softening of the ultimate penalty doesn't hide the fact that this is a gross miscarriage of justice.
In truth, it may not be all that surprising that Admiral Grimitz butchered the legal niceties here. In this ep, he pretty much ruins whatever small reputation had accrued to him during his previous appearances in the series. Overbearing and "lunkheadish" he may have been before this, but he seemed at least marginally competent during the mission to stop Dr. Bluebottle's stolen sub in "A Whale of a Bad Time." The lazy way to write such a character would be to turn him into some kind of buffoonish, sea-going version of Dr. Strangelove's Jack D. Ripper. Well, it took a while for the "Kablooey"s and obsession with toy boats -- er, "Pentagon-issue naval battle simulators" -- to appear, but we got them in spades here. As if to emphasize the turn to a more comedic (at least in theory) characterization, the admiral's legs seem barely able to support his body at numerous points. Launchpad suffered very much the same top-heavy redesign in Darkwing Duck, and we all know what happened to LP's general level of intelligence along with that.
One particularly disturbing aspect of Grimitz' deterioration as a character is his seeming indifference to Donald's plight. I wouldn't say that he takes actual pleasure at the prospect of cashiering Don, but he certainly doesn't seem all that worried about investigating the matter to the bottom, laughing off Scrooge's hypnosis theory and such. This aspect of the ep has always left a bad taste in my mouth. Grimitz would at least partially redeem himself with a slightly better performance in "All Ducks on Deck," but he lost a fatal amount of ground here. Thankfully, when Quack Pack did its "Donald returns to the Navy" episode "All Hands on Duck," it left Grimitz blessedly alone to nurse what remained of his battered rep.
As if to take up the slack for his superior's newly-minted inferiority, Donald delivers a solid, and occasionally even admirable, performance. We get the standard amount of bungling, to be sure, but Don's refusal to talk about the secret sub with Scrooge, even when the two of them are the only ones present, lends credence to Scrooge's musing that the Navy has helped give Don some maturity. Don's actions under hypnosis are, of course, not his fault, and he doesn't hesitate to pursue the stolen sub all by himself. Despite being hypnotized, he's considerably less of a "pawn" here than he was during "Sphinx for the Memories," and the character traits that he is allowed to display here tend to flatter him, rather than put him in a bad light.
"Spies"' other significant demerit concerns Wang Films' animation. No, actually, I should be a bit more precise and say "Wang's figure drawing." To say that the latter is "all over the place" during this episode is to insult the very nature of randomness. It is tough to believe that the two versions of Donald shown below could have appeared in the same 22-minute production:
Likewise, check out these two versions of Victor Luzer. Did Wang have the "T-team" (no, not that one!) working on the first scene (which is "merely" the scene in which we are introduced to Victor)?
The shame of it all is that, while Wang's character animators really let them down here, their background personnel came up "aces full" with some impressive and imaginative visuals. The street scenes in Singapore (minus the "stereotyped" Asian characters, who, for the most part, aren't all that offensive) are fairly bland, with the occasional bit of intriguing lagniappe tossed in, such as the "go-go girl" sign at the upper right of Don's notorious "The night is young, and I'm old enough!" scene...
... but the Wang crew suddenly gets a bit fancy at the spy-infested Cloak & Dagger Club, tossing in well-composed long shots and clever overhead views of Cinnamon Teal's booby-trapped booth.
We get similarly strong background work when the hypnotized Donald enters the carrier and the submarine and steals the computer link. (True confessions time: I didn't really notice the bad character designs until I made heavy use of freeze-frame while preparing this commentary. At normal speed, the flow of the animation tended to obscure some of the more egregious anatomical violations.)
It is eminently probable that much of the supporting voice cast of this episode was chosen with a purpose in mind. Victor Luzer is not only a(n) (un) worthy successor to Carl Barks' procession of nasty, arrogant pig villains -- so much so, in fact, that it's a bit surprising that he didn't simply demand that Donald be "permanently silenced" after Cinnamon Teal brought the latter out of his trance -- but an homage to Bernie Kopell's KAOS agent, Siegfried, from Get Smart.
Meanwhile, the choice of Haunani Minn as the sultry voice of Cinnamon Teal originally seemed like typical "Asian typecasting" to me, but not so fast: Minn played the role of a North Korean guerrilla woman in the 1979 M*A*S*H episode "Guerrilla My Dreams." (This was the notorious [at least, back in the day] episode in which Hawkeye said "SOB" on prime-time TV.) Did someone at WDTVA remember this show and figure that someone who could play a guerrilla so memorably could also play a spy?
Cinnamon Teal, of course, would make a comeback in kaboom!'s TV-Duck comics, appearing in both "Rightful Owners" (first appearance... sigh... kaboom! DUCKTALES #3) and the concluding DUCKTALES/DARKWING DUCK arc, "Dangerous Currency." At the time, I remember shedding a figurative tear at the thought that Cinnamon had "fallen back into evil ways" following her bout of cooperation with Scrooge and HD&L. Now, however, I would qualify that claim and admit that there was no real evidence that she actually DID reform as a result of "Spies." She simply formed a mariage de convenience with the good guys for the purposes of getting the real documents back from the treacherous Victor. Her "return to the dark side" still strikes me as a little disappointing, nonetheless. I mean, Scrooge saw his way clear to offer the Beagle Babes a job after they kidnapped Webby; why couldn't he have done the same for a "promised to be good" Cinnamon?
"Spies" is a fairly solid effort with a couple of strong one-shot (at least in animated form) guest villains livening things up considerably, but I can't rate it with the series' four-star eps for a couple of key reasons. The theme of Donald being falsely accused of "espionage and high treason" could have made for a really thrilling denouement, with Scrooge, HD&L, and their temporary ally Cinnamon Teal hustling to stop superspy Victor Luzer's theft of the "attack sub experimental" and prove Donald's innocence before Donald is subjected to a court-martial. Since the real penalty that would have been facing Seaman Duck for such crimes would have been death or, at the very least, lengthy imprisonment at hard labor, the others' goal would have been to preempt the legal proceedings themselves. Here, however, writers Sharman DiVono and Bruce Reid Schaefer seem to get their legal wires crossed and conflate the "court martial" with Donald being "drummed out of the Navy." In other words, Donald has every right to whine in the scene below, because he's the victim in what amounts to a show trial. "Sentence first, verdict afterwards!" The softening of the ultimate penalty doesn't hide the fact that this is a gross miscarriage of justice.
In truth, it may not be all that surprising that Admiral Grimitz butchered the legal niceties here. In this ep, he pretty much ruins whatever small reputation had accrued to him during his previous appearances in the series. Overbearing and "lunkheadish" he may have been before this, but he seemed at least marginally competent during the mission to stop Dr. Bluebottle's stolen sub in "A Whale of a Bad Time." The lazy way to write such a character would be to turn him into some kind of buffoonish, sea-going version of Dr. Strangelove's Jack D. Ripper. Well, it took a while for the "Kablooey"s and obsession with toy boats -- er, "Pentagon-issue naval battle simulators" -- to appear, but we got them in spades here. As if to emphasize the turn to a more comedic (at least in theory) characterization, the admiral's legs seem barely able to support his body at numerous points. Launchpad suffered very much the same top-heavy redesign in Darkwing Duck, and we all know what happened to LP's general level of intelligence along with that.
One particularly disturbing aspect of Grimitz' deterioration as a character is his seeming indifference to Donald's plight. I wouldn't say that he takes actual pleasure at the prospect of cashiering Don, but he certainly doesn't seem all that worried about investigating the matter to the bottom, laughing off Scrooge's hypnosis theory and such. This aspect of the ep has always left a bad taste in my mouth. Grimitz would at least partially redeem himself with a slightly better performance in "All Ducks on Deck," but he lost a fatal amount of ground here. Thankfully, when Quack Pack did its "Donald returns to the Navy" episode "All Hands on Duck," it left Grimitz blessedly alone to nurse what remained of his battered rep.
As if to take up the slack for his superior's newly-minted inferiority, Donald delivers a solid, and occasionally even admirable, performance. We get the standard amount of bungling, to be sure, but Don's refusal to talk about the secret sub with Scrooge, even when the two of them are the only ones present, lends credence to Scrooge's musing that the Navy has helped give Don some maturity. Don's actions under hypnosis are, of course, not his fault, and he doesn't hesitate to pursue the stolen sub all by himself. Despite being hypnotized, he's considerably less of a "pawn" here than he was during "Sphinx for the Memories," and the character traits that he is allowed to display here tend to flatter him, rather than put him in a bad light.
"Spies"' other significant demerit concerns Wang Films' animation. No, actually, I should be a bit more precise and say "Wang's figure drawing." To say that the latter is "all over the place" during this episode is to insult the very nature of randomness. It is tough to believe that the two versions of Donald shown below could have appeared in the same 22-minute production:
Likewise, check out these two versions of Victor Luzer. Did Wang have the "T-team" (no, not that one!) working on the first scene (which is "merely" the scene in which we are introduced to Victor)?
The shame of it all is that, while Wang's character animators really let them down here, their background personnel came up "aces full" with some impressive and imaginative visuals. The street scenes in Singapore (minus the "stereotyped" Asian characters, who, for the most part, aren't all that offensive) are fairly bland, with the occasional bit of intriguing lagniappe tossed in, such as the "go-go girl" sign at the upper right of Don's notorious "The night is young, and I'm old enough!" scene...
... but the Wang crew suddenly gets a bit fancy at the spy-infested Cloak & Dagger Club, tossing in well-composed long shots and clever overhead views of Cinnamon Teal's booby-trapped booth.
We get similarly strong background work when the hypnotized Donald enters the carrier and the submarine and steals the computer link. (True confessions time: I didn't really notice the bad character designs until I made heavy use of freeze-frame while preparing this commentary. At normal speed, the flow of the animation tended to obscure some of the more egregious anatomical violations.)
It is eminently probable that much of the supporting voice cast of this episode was chosen with a purpose in mind. Victor Luzer is not only a(n) (un) worthy successor to Carl Barks' procession of nasty, arrogant pig villains -- so much so, in fact, that it's a bit surprising that he didn't simply demand that Donald be "permanently silenced" after Cinnamon Teal brought the latter out of his trance -- but an homage to Bernie Kopell's KAOS agent, Siegfried, from Get Smart.
Meanwhile, the choice of Haunani Minn as the sultry voice of Cinnamon Teal originally seemed like typical "Asian typecasting" to me, but not so fast: Minn played the role of a North Korean guerrilla woman in the 1979 M*A*S*H episode "Guerrilla My Dreams." (This was the notorious [at least, back in the day] episode in which Hawkeye said "SOB" on prime-time TV.) Did someone at WDTVA remember this show and figure that someone who could play a guerrilla so memorably could also play a spy?
Cinnamon Teal, of course, would make a comeback in kaboom!'s TV-Duck comics, appearing in both "Rightful Owners" (first appearance... sigh... kaboom! DUCKTALES #3) and the concluding DUCKTALES/DARKWING DUCK arc, "Dangerous Currency." At the time, I remember shedding a figurative tear at the thought that Cinnamon had "fallen back into evil ways" following her bout of cooperation with Scrooge and HD&L. Now, however, I would qualify that claim and admit that there was no real evidence that she actually DID reform as a result of "Spies." She simply formed a mariage de convenience with the good guys for the purposes of getting the real documents back from the treacherous Victor. Her "return to the dark side" still strikes me as a little disappointing, nonetheless. I mean, Scrooge saw his way clear to offer the Beagle Babes a job after they kidnapped Webby; why couldn't he have done the same for a "promised to be good" Cinnamon?
No comment -- either visually or verbally.
Next stop... er... disgrace and extra-dimensional exile in a pile of slime.
The other major one-shot player we get here, Cinnamon Teal's cousin and "silent partner" Ho, might as well have been excluded for all he meaningfully contributes to the fun. Why even bother introducing him if he completely disappears immediately after the scene in the basement of the Cloak & Dagger Club? Why not simply have Scrooge and HD&L get knocked out from their fall into the basement, then have Cinnamon revive them and plead for their help herself? About all that Ho provides (aside from fodder for the groan-inducing Snow White pun) is a bit more fuel to the fire of complaint about the series' overuse of "Asian stereotypes."
The episode's climactic action gives all the major players something to do -- well, all except HD&L, which, given their earlier gung-ho attitude about plunging into a nest full of spies and intrigue, seems an odd omission. GeoX's complaint that Victor abandons subtlety in favor of "blasting at ships for no stated reason" can be answered by noting that Admiral Grimitz has, after all, tried to "block the port of Singapore" with the carrier (and, as Greg pointed out, that would be a rather tough real-life assignment; check out the map below), so how else could Victor be expected to react in order to secure his escape. We even get a couple of (non-lethal) "Kablooey"s for good measure, the better to soothe Grimitz' soul just a wee bit after that embarrassing turn as a danseur.
The ending is logically dubious -- unless you accept the theory that documents can't be copied in the Duck "universe," that is -- but Geo's conclusion that this is "a pretty good episode all told" seems just about right. Unfortunately, "All Ducks on Deck" turned out to be so much better than "Spies" on so many levels that the generally decent quality of the latter episode tends to be forgotten today.
.
.
.
"DuckBlurbs"
(GeoX) He's a DUCK--TALES--HERO, got spies in his eyes! Sorry, but I fail to see how anyone can talk about this episode and not use that one.
Er, ah... "Pinball Wizard" reference?? Otherwise, I haven't got a clue.
(GeoX) Louie: "What's hypnosis?" Dewey: "It's when you walk around in a daze and don't know what you're doing!" [Louie:] "That sounds like Unca Donald, all right!" No, it sounds like the forced setup for a stupid joke at the expense of character. STOP DOING THAT.
Especially since it has long since been established that the DuckTales Nephews, though they do recognize Donald's fallibility, respect him too much to be willing to indulge in such a crude and obvious insult. Given that the lads willingly "dorked out" and "flashed" Donald with cameras when they first met him on the streets of Singapore, I don't think that they're in any position to be tossing stones here.
(Greg) Donald gulps as MP #1 (MP's are the privates of the Navy see. He's the fat dogsperson on the headphones) calls for the attack sonar to engage and MP #2 calls for attack computers are engaged as a smaller MP in sailor gear mans the computers and somehow doesn't speak.
Actually, the two members of Shore Patrol (not MP's... my bad) are the guys who arrest Donald at the end of Act One. The dogfaces in the sub are simply "generic" sailors, while the gig driver (also not an MP) is the one who ferries Donald to and from Singapore.
(Greg) Ducktales is [Bernie Kopell]'s only DTVA appearance and in fact probably the only cartoon he was in.
Kopell appeared in at least two other animated series: The Lionhearts (Remember? The series that tried to make Leo, the MGM lion, into a cartoon star?) and As Told by Ginger.
(Greg) So we head to Singapore as the far shot looks like a regular city in America (bad sign for the writers right there) and then we cut to town level as we see the Asian Stereotypical buildings and then go to ground level as we see a decent amount of Asian dogsperson stereotypes strewed out for all to see. A man yells out there are fresh spices from India, Africa and China (and no I don't know who is voicing him; so don't ask).
I think it was Ed Gilbert, but I'm not absolutely sure. The Toon Disney version of the ep cut out this line, segueing straight from the long shot of Singapore to the marketplace scene with the HD&L voiceover. No... sense... making...
(Greg) So Scrooge punishes [Cinnamon] by pushing her into the ocean and she splashes down. I smell Toon Disney cut here...
No, the scene was preserved. Perhaps "male on female contact violence" was deemed OK in this situation because Cinnamon was technically a villain?
Next: Episode 55, "Launchpad's First Crash."
.
.
.
"DuckBlurbs"
(GeoX) He's a DUCK--TALES--HERO, got spies in his eyes! Sorry, but I fail to see how anyone can talk about this episode and not use that one.
Er, ah... "Pinball Wizard" reference?? Otherwise, I haven't got a clue.
(GeoX) Louie: "What's hypnosis?" Dewey: "It's when you walk around in a daze and don't know what you're doing!" [Louie:] "That sounds like Unca Donald, all right!" No, it sounds like the forced setup for a stupid joke at the expense of character. STOP DOING THAT.
Especially since it has long since been established that the DuckTales Nephews, though they do recognize Donald's fallibility, respect him too much to be willing to indulge in such a crude and obvious insult. Given that the lads willingly "dorked out" and "flashed" Donald with cameras when they first met him on the streets of Singapore, I don't think that they're in any position to be tossing stones here.
(Greg) Donald gulps as MP #1 (MP's are the privates of the Navy see. He's the fat dogsperson on the headphones) calls for the attack sonar to engage and MP #2 calls for attack computers are engaged as a smaller MP in sailor gear mans the computers and somehow doesn't speak.
Actually, the two members of Shore Patrol (not MP's... my bad) are the guys who arrest Donald at the end of Act One. The dogfaces in the sub are simply "generic" sailors, while the gig driver (also not an MP) is the one who ferries Donald to and from Singapore.
(Greg) Ducktales is [Bernie Kopell]'s only DTVA appearance and in fact probably the only cartoon he was in.
Kopell appeared in at least two other animated series: The Lionhearts (Remember? The series that tried to make Leo, the MGM lion, into a cartoon star?) and As Told by Ginger.
(Greg) So we head to Singapore as the far shot looks like a regular city in America (bad sign for the writers right there) and then we cut to town level as we see the Asian Stereotypical buildings and then go to ground level as we see a decent amount of Asian dogsperson stereotypes strewed out for all to see. A man yells out there are fresh spices from India, Africa and China (and no I don't know who is voicing him; so don't ask).
I think it was Ed Gilbert, but I'm not absolutely sure. The Toon Disney version of the ep cut out this line, segueing straight from the long shot of Singapore to the marketplace scene with the HD&L voiceover. No... sense... making...
(Greg) So Scrooge punishes [Cinnamon] by pushing her into the ocean and she splashes down. I smell Toon Disney cut here...
No, the scene was preserved. Perhaps "male on female contact violence" was deemed OK in this situation because Cinnamon was technically a villain?
Next: Episode 55, "Launchpad's First Crash."
Labels:
Animation,
Carl Barks,
Darkwing Duck,
Disney Afternoon,
Disney comics,
DuckTales,
Live Television,
Movies,
Music,
Novels,
Quack Pack
Sunday, September 22, 2013
Book Review: LINCOLN UNBOUND by Rich Lowry (Broadside Books, 2013)
"Getting right with Lincoln" has long been a pastime of American politicians on both sides of the political spectrum. More recently, progressives have expended much energy in reinterpreting "Honest Abe" as one of their own, someone who would have had no problem whatsoever with the growth of the welfare state and big government in general. Lowry, the editor of NATIONAL REVIEW, doesn't contend the assertion that Lincoln was, in fact, a proponent of an activist federal government; indeed, a certain segment of conservative opinion regards Lincoln as a villain for some of the drastic actions he took during the Civil War to combat dissension and outright treason in the Northern states. But he makes the compelling case that Lincoln's activism sought not to lock people into a cycle of dependency, but rather, to give them a chance to better themselves in a dynamic, ever-changing capitalist society. At the same time, without being preachy, Lincoln, through his behavior and words, exemplified a "bourgeois morality" that would increase the chances for people to find and maintain success.
Lowry believes that today's Republican Party would do well to go back to "first Lincolnian principles" and emphasize the importance of rebuilding an "opportunity society," as opposed to simply opposing the growth of government. The problem with this, as I see it, is that there is such a crying need for immediate governmental contraction that making simple progress on that front must necessarily precede any efforts towards making the government more efficient, less heavy-handed, and more capable of aiding citizens without trying to dominate their lives. Still, it is refreshing to note Lowry's recognition that government can play its small part to encourage industry, education, and basic research and to improve infrastructure, provided that it imbibes a little Lincolnian common sense. On the issue of cultural change, things are trickier, because popular culture is far more pervasive and easily disseminated today than in the 1850s and 1860s, and the "cultural elites" will need a change of heart (and, IMHO, stronger financial competition from cultural products with a friendlier view of traditional Judeo-Christian morality) before they are willing to play a more positive role in keeping the foundations of the culture strong. Delivering messages of "uplift" imbued with a sense of humor and a clear recognition of human foibles, as Lincoln frequently did, would be a good start.
LINCOLN UNBOUND presents an unconventional view of our greatest President, but one that ought to be seriously considered and debated by all citizens in terms of how it might provide some guidance in our troubled times.
Lowry believes that today's Republican Party would do well to go back to "first Lincolnian principles" and emphasize the importance of rebuilding an "opportunity society," as opposed to simply opposing the growth of government. The problem with this, as I see it, is that there is such a crying need for immediate governmental contraction that making simple progress on that front must necessarily precede any efforts towards making the government more efficient, less heavy-handed, and more capable of aiding citizens without trying to dominate their lives. Still, it is refreshing to note Lowry's recognition that government can play its small part to encourage industry, education, and basic research and to improve infrastructure, provided that it imbibes a little Lincolnian common sense. On the issue of cultural change, things are trickier, because popular culture is far more pervasive and easily disseminated today than in the 1850s and 1860s, and the "cultural elites" will need a change of heart (and, IMHO, stronger financial competition from cultural products with a friendlier view of traditional Judeo-Christian morality) before they are willing to play a more positive role in keeping the foundations of the culture strong. Delivering messages of "uplift" imbued with a sense of humor and a clear recognition of human foibles, as Lincoln frequently did, would be a good start.
LINCOLN UNBOUND presents an unconventional view of our greatest President, but one that ought to be seriously considered and debated by all citizens in terms of how it might provide some guidance in our troubled times.
Saturday, September 21, 2013
Stevenson 55, FDU-Florham 22
Now comes the real test: games against Delaware Valley (road) and Widener (home) during the next two weeks. These teams are the top duo in the conference and have thrashed SU every time they have played. Even a 1-1 split would seem to be a lot to hope for under the circs, but this team has already surpassed expectations.
Stevenson's rise is starting to get a little national attention: witness this column on D3football.com.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
































